🔁 Rhythm and Fuel: How Two Complementary Models Explain Your Body’s Hidden Metabolic Struggles

The CACH and ERM frameworks reveal why resilience isn’t just about stress or rest — it’s about the tempo and the resources to sustain it.

We’re not just stressed or tired — we’re metabolically mismatched. A new model of resilience (CACH) shows how the body builds strength through cycles of stress and recovery. But what if the cycle breaks down? A second model (ERM) explains why substrate depletion, not just stress, may be the real root of fatigue, poor recovery, and accelerated aging.

🌀 Rhythm and Fuel

What if your fatigue, brain fog, or slow recovery isn’t a failure — but a metabolic mismatch?

Two powerful biological models are helping us understand why some people thrive under stress — and others don’t. One describes the rhythm of resilience. The other reveals what happens when the system runs low on energy and materials.

Together, they offer a missing-link explanation for modern metabolic dysfunction — and a way forward.

🔁 CACH: The Rhythmic Pulse of Resilience

In a recent landmark study, researchers Edward Calabrese and Mark Mattson proposed the Catabolic–Anabolic Cycling Hormesis (CACH) model [1]. It’s built on a simple but powerful premise:

Health and resilience emerge through rhythmic cycles of stress and recovery.

Each cycle involves:

• Catabolic phase → challenge, adaptation (e.g., exercise, fasting)

• Anabolic phase → restoration, growth (e.g., eating, sleeping)

This cycling stimulates mitochondrial renewal, protein repair, immune tuning, and neural plasticity. It’s why habits like intermittent fasting, strength training, or sauna exposure work so well.

But CACH assumes the body can cycle.

⚠️ ERM: When the System Can’t Recover

Enter Exposure-Related Malnutrition (ERM) — a proposed bioenergetic framework that explains what happens when the cycle breaks down [2].

ERM shows how chronic stress, inflammation, and nutrient mismatch can lead to metabolic depletion — even in people eating enough calories.

The result?

• Persistent fatigue

• Impaired repair

• Sarcopenia

• Brain fog

• Subclinical inflammation

The ERM model proposes that unresolved catabolism, blocked recovery, and substrate misallocation (especially under chronic stress) lead to systemic exhaustion and early biological aging.

In ERM, the rhythm is there — but the instrument is out of tune and running on fumes.

🔗 Tempo × Fuel = Resilience

CACH and ERM aren’t competing theories — they complement each other:

Concept	CACH	ERM
Focus	How we adapt (cycling rhythm)	Whether we can adapt (substrate availability)
Core idea	Stress-recovery builds resilience	Chronic mismatch depletes it
Analogy	The drumbeat	The drumsticks and drummer’s stamina

✅ CACH gives you the rhythm. ERM makes sure you have the resources to dance.

🧭 Practical Implications

If you’re feeling stuck, tired, or inflamed despite doing “all the right things” — fasting, cold plunges, HIIT — the issue may not be willpower or discipline.

Ask:

• Am I adequately fueled?

• Is my recovery sufficient?

• Do I have the bioenergetic foundation to benefit from the stress?

You may need to restore substrate availability first — amino acids, micronutrients, mitochondrial cofactors — before layering on more stress.

🌱 The Takeaway

Health isn’t a straight line. It’s a rhythm — but rhythm alone isn’t enough.

• CACH explains how we build resilience.

• ERM explains why we lose it.

Together, they illuminate the real path forward:

You’re not broken — you’re out of rhythm, and running on empty.

Restore the rhythm. Replenish the fuel. That’s the new roadmap to resilience.

 Want More?

If you're interested in resilience science, metabolic health, or why modern stress is biologically expensive — hit subscribe for more insights like this. Future posts will explore:

• How ERM manifests in lab tests

• Metabolic staging of exhaustion

• Why protein timing matters more than we think

#CACH #ERM #Resilience #Hormesis #MetabolicHealth #ChronicStress #Fatigue #NutritionScience

📚 References

1. Calabrese EJ, Mattson MP. The catabolic–anabolic cycling hormesis model of health and resilience. Ageing Res Rev. 2024;102:102588. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arr.2024.102588

2. Tippairote T., et. al. From Adaptation to Exhaustion: Defining Exposure-Related Malnutrition as a Bioenergetic Phenotype of Aging. Preprint. 2025. https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202504.1142.v3Currently under peer review at Biogerontology

💬 Enjoyed this piece?

Subscribe on Substack for direct updates, or read more articles on my blog.